>>> Hi Bill, many thanks for the reply. Has taken a little while to sink in
>>> But
[quoted text clipped - 28 lines]
> tunneling from the outside world into the private network and then use
> RDP to the guests?
>>>> Hi Bill, many thanks for the reply. Has taken a little while to sink in
>>>> But
[quoted text clipped - 38 lines]
> I control the server from a Vista workstation on the LAN, not from the
>host. The host is a headless server that just sits there and runs vms.
To me this is tyhe same thing, the PC from which you RDP into the
guests must be able to reach them and so the virtual network cannot be
completely isolated from the outside network where your own PC
resides.
> You could certainly use VPN to connect to the private LAN behind the NAT
>router if you wanted that option. A virtual network is really no different
>from a physical one. The networking software doesn't even know which it is
>running on. One of the first virtual networks I set up was to emulate a
>site-to-site VPN link. It connected two sites running under VPC on two
>workstations. Each site had a client machine and a RRAS router.
My point for asking is that the OP wanted to RDP into the guests and
if the guests were on private network that network must be accessible
from outside. This could be done with RRAS on a single guest with two
NIC:s, one in the private network and the other on the outside
network. RRAS because it must be capable of establishing a VPN tunnel
since the connection is from outside. NAT won't do, but is enough for
the VM:s to reach the Internet.
I guess that one could also skip the VPN step and just set up a simple
routing scheme, but then I think the guest running RRAS must be set as
the default gateway on the "outside" PC:s, which probably is not very
good....
I have been running a VS2005 guest with Win2003 as a RRAS router since
about 2 years in order to handle my own VPN access from the Internet
into my home LAN via the ADSL router. Before that I hade a physical
Win2000 server doing the same thing for many years.
My VS2005 host is XP-Pro SP2.
The virtualized solution works as good as the physical one except for
recurring problems of getting the guest to start up automatically
after power outages.
Virtualization saves me one PC and therefore also the energy for that.
:-)

Signature
Bo Berglund (Sweden)